SUBSCRIBE

Breaking News on Supplements, Health & Nutrition - Europe US edition | APAC edition

Read more breaking news

 

 
Dispatches from the #SNC16 congress in Frankfurt

Could energy drinks be cut out of the EU caffeine claim loop?

By Annie-Rose Harrison-Dunn+

20-Dec-2016
Last updated on 20-Dec-2016 at 14:58 GMT2016-12-20T14:58:17Z

'Rather than throwing the baby out with the bathwater we just need to look at it and find a way of making sure the vulnerable consumer is protected,' says GSK. ©iStock/EldadCarin

'Rather than throwing the baby out with the bathwater we just need to look at it and find a way of making sure the vulnerable consumer is protected,' says GSK. ©iStock/EldadCarin

The European Specialist Sports Nutrition Alliance (ESSNA) is lobbying for two different solutions to the EU caffeine claim hold up, one of which could see use of the claims limited to sports supplements only.  

Five years after the European Food Safety Authority (EFSA) gave its thumbs to the science behind five caffeine health claims, controversy on their official approval for use rumbles on.

A report on safe upper limits from EFSA last year meant one of the claims referring to ‘perceived exertion during exercise’ was cast aside for good.  

Then this year members of the European Parliament (MEPs) blocked a draft proposal to finally write the other four claims, doses for which fell within EFSA’s safe limits, into EU law books.

After heated dialogue on energy drink consumption and obesity among young people, the MEPs sent the European Commission  back to the drawing board .

The four pending claims are: 

  • “Caffeine contributes to an increase in endurance performance.” [sports population]
  • “Caffeine contributes to an increase in endurance capacity.” [sports population]
  • “Caffeine helps to increase alertness.” [general population]
  • “Caffeine helps to improve concentration.” [general population]

A fifth claim has already been rejected: “Caffeine contributes to a reduction in the rated perceived exertion/effort during exercise.”

At the recent Sports Nutrition Conference (#SNC16) organised by NutraIngredients in partnership with ESSNA, Maria Thijssen, regulatory affairs manager for ESSNA member company Nutritional GSK (GlaxoSmithKline), told us industry was lobbying for one of two solutions for the claims.

Lobbying for a solution 

One option suggests the current draft single annex amendment – which ties the fate of all four claims – is split into two separate amendments for the two sports-specific claims and the two general population claims on alertness and concentration.  

“As we currently stand, if [the European Parliament] aren’t happy with two of the claims, they can’t approve all four. So that’s the dilemma we’re in at the moment,” Thijssen said.

Another option could be to alter the terms of the claims so that they can only be used on food supplement products, not energy drinks, or that the claims are used only on products marketed specifically for sportspeople.

“That could help eliminate sugary drinks from being allowed to use the claims,” she said.  

Parliamentary debates on the claims centred largely on the potential health halo that could be created over sugary energy drinks, which the MEPs said would exacerbate the obesity crisis.

Doing it for the kids

“I think that the fact that we’ve identified vulnerable [young] consumers should make every FBO [food business operator] stand up and acknowledge that we’ve got a vulnerable consumer, they’re suffering as a result, it’s something that is very real and it is happening.”

She said industry had a responsibility to work with the European Commission, Parliament and EU member state governments to tackle the issue of obesity.

However she added this should be done without “limiting or over-restricting” products that could hold big benefits for sportspeople.

“Rather than throwing the baby out with the bathwater we just need to look at it and find a way of making sure the vulnerable consumer, which is the adolescent, is protected.”

©iStock/littlehenrabi

She said the caffeine controversy had shown that claims are more likely to be approved if they specified a target population.

Yet how easy is this when the sports nutrition industry is increasingly broadening its  consumer group ?

At the #SNC16 event, many of the speakers discussed this category blurring, with products not traditionally included in the market brought into the fold to target less hardcore, more casually 'active' groups. 

Asked if the marketing of sports products should be restricted to sportspeople to avoid the uproar seen in the parliamentary debates, she said these products were still relevant for people who did not consider themselves athletes or even committed gym goers but who had set themselves a personal goal of, for example, running a half marathon.

‘The spirit of the law is that you protect your consumer’

Ultimately she said the issue went beyond sticking to the letter of EU law and to a company’s responsibility to make safe products that don’t mislead the consumer.

“So even if you were complying with all the rules and we still had this problem, it would be something that in the spirit of the legislation we’d still have to turn around and look at.

“It’s not something we can just carry on blindly going: ‘No, no, no, we comply with the law we’re not going to think about it.’ You have to, because essentially the spirit of the law is that you protect your consumer, especially protecting vulnerable groups of people, and you’re trying to market a safe and effective product.”

Despite caffeine’s well-known effects of alertness, she said claims were important because “if over time that information starts disappearing from packaging, then people will forget”.

Related products

Milk protein producer not ready throw in towel to whey

Milk protein producer not ready throw in towel to whey

Milk proteins continue to carve out a strong niche in sports nutrition despite’s whey...

Just Thrive Probiotic chosen for HIV trial, company says

Just Thrive Probiotic chosen for HIV trial, company says

Thrive Probiotic has gathered data on the company’s Just Thrive Probiotic supplement and its...

Synbio ingredients have vast market penetration, new list shows

Synbio ingredients have vast market penetration, new list shows

Synthetic biology, or GMO 2.0 as some are calling it, has vastly more penetration...

FOODVISION: Trust and ethics key to reaching consumer hearts and minds

FOODVISION: Trust and ethics key to reaching consumer hearts and minds

Erin Boyd Kappelhof

Managing Partner, Eat Well Global

FOODVISION: DNA testing just ‘one part of the jigsaw’

FOODVISION: DNA testing just ‘one part of the jigsaw’

Andrew Steele

Head of Product Development, DNAFit

From marketing to taste: How virtual reality will change the food industry

From marketing to taste: How virtual reality will change the food industry

Virtual reality has arrived and is set to change the way the food industry...

Is pharma interest in probiotics a challenge or opportunity?

Is pharma interest in probiotics a challenge or opportunity?

The probiotic category continues to grow rapidly on a global basis. And with growth...

Food Vision: Insights and highlights from day one in London

Food Vision: Insights and highlights from day one in London

Food Vision kicked off yesterday with insights from innovation specialists and trailblazing startups. Join...

Probiota Insights: Which probiotic formats hold the most exciting future potential?

Probiota Insights: Which probiotic formats hold the most exciting future potential?

There is a huge focus on finding 'the next big thing' in terms of...

Overcoming the taboo of vaginal health – the next frontier of probiotics

Overcoming the taboo of vaginal health – the next frontier of probiotics

A paradigm shift is needed to force delicate women’s health issues like vaginal infections...

FiE 2015: Our best bits

FiE 2015: Our best bits

Our teams of journalists were out in force at Food Ingredients Europe (FiE) last...

New tech on EFSA’s horizon: Crowdsourcing and cyber assistants

New tech on EFSA’s horizon: Crowdsourcing and cyber assistants

New technology like crowdsourcing and artificial intelligence computers is the future of risk assessment,...

EFSA’s Bernhard Url: Science should reserve one private room for open debate

EFSA’s Bernhard Url: Science should reserve one private room for open debate

Since taking the European Food Safety Authority (EFSA) throne last summer, Dr Bernhard Url has become...

Seadragon sets out to breathe fire into Kiwi fish oil

Seadragon sets out to breathe fire into Kiwi fish oil

The town of Nelson will welcome New Zealand's first omega-3 fish oil processing plant...

The taste test: How do you make a probiotic drink taste good?

The taste test: How do you make a probiotic drink taste good?

Probiotic fruit drinks face different challenges to their dairy counterparts - but both face...

African probiotic project reaching 10,000 infants a day

African probiotic project reaching 10,000 infants a day

Professor Gregor Reid

Chair , University of Western Ontario & Human Microbiology and...

Germvangelist set to shake Probiota with holistic shout

Germvangelist set to shake Probiota with holistic shout

Jason Tetro

Researcher, author, The Germ Guy

Creepy proteins will be hot

New proteins are creeping on trend

Alternative proteins are a “hot area” of interest and products such as sandwich spreads...

Dairy ingredients giant on Indonesia: ‘A lot of opportunities here’

Dairy ingredients giant on Indonesia: ‘A lot of opportunities here’

Jake Riddle

General manager, Kerry Asia Pacific