Breaking News on Supplements & Nutrition - EuropeUS edition

Headlines > Regulation

Exclusive interview

Health claims chief highlights EFSA’s compromised comms policy

By Shane Starling, 28-Jun-2010

Related topics: Health claims, Regulation

Professor Albert Flynn, chair of European Food Safety Authority’s Scientific Panel on Dietetic Products, Nutrition and Allergies (NDA) tells Shane Starling how its communication ambitions are being thwarted by a lack of funding.

Loading...

Interview with Professor Albert Flynn
Chair, European Food Safety Authority Scientific Panel on Dietetic Products, Nutrition and Allergies (NDA)

The NDA is the European Union’s much-maligned health claims panel. It recently hosted a congress at its headquarters in Parma, Italy, where about 400 industry members turned up with dossiers of urgent questions about their rejected health claim dossiers.

One of the key concerns was the NDA’s communication with applicants – or lack of it. Professor Flynn said the agency and the NDA wants to be chattier but is restrained by a lack of cash and is therefore forced to be selective about who it talks to.

“Clearly if one applicant can have a meeting then indeed all are entitled to it so it just very difficult to provide the opportunity for every applicant to have meetings,” said Professor Flynn.

“We have no way of selecting in any kind of fair way why some applicants should have a meeting and why others wouldn’t. That is part of our difficulty – that if one applicant has a meeting then others will clearly will feel that they are entitled to one as well. It becomes a major resource issue if we have to meetings with every applicant and clearly we can’t treat applicants differently.”

“For the moment we are looking at what can be done in terms of communication overall with the individual applicants. It’s something we have under review all the time to see whether it can be improved for the applicant and also indeed for EFSA.”

Look to NutraIngredients for further excerpts from this Podcast where Professor Flynn refutes criticism that the agency is unevenly applying scientific criteria.

Ocean Spray backed research reveals cranberry polyphenols in human urine

Ocean Spray backed research reveals cranberry polyphenols in human urine

Professor Jeffrey Blumberg

Director, Antioxidants Research Laboratory, Tufts University

Food waste has big potential for value-added ingredients

Food waste has big potential for value-added ingredients

Dr Charis Galanakis

visiting lecturer, Cyprus University of Technology

The father of nutraceuticals: “The placebo effect is real”

The father of nutraceuticals: “The placebo effect is real”

Dr Stephen de Felice

Founder and chairman, Foundation for Innovation in Medicine

WWF backs krill fishery as new data and better harvest methods surface

WWF backs krill fishery as new data and better harvest methods surface

Karoline Andaur

Head of the marine programme, World Wildlife Fund Norway

PepsiCo on nutrient profiling: “We are operating in a legal vacuum”

PepsiCo on nutrient profiling: “We are operating in a legal vacuum”

Dr Natalia Douek, regulatory affairs director, PepsiCo Europe;

Dr Mike Rayner, director, British Heart Foundation Health Promotion Research...

EPHA on food industry taxation: “The time for a free-for-all is finished”

EPHA on food industry taxation: “The time for a free-for-all is finished”

Monika Kosinska

Secretary general, European Public Health Alliance

6-year EU obesity platform nears completion: But has it worked?

6-year EU obesity platform nears completion: But has it worked?

Despina Spanou

Principal advisor, European Commission Directorate General for Health and Consumers,...

Tough? Not tough enough, says UK watchdog on EU health claim rules

Tough? Not tough enough, says UK watchdog on EU health claim rules

Sue Davies

Chief food policy advisor, Which?

Institute of Food Research launch industry group for healthy food structures

Institute of Food Research launch industry group for healthy food structures

Professor Tim Brocklehurst

head of food & health network, Institute of Food Research, UK.

Julie Girling MEP: “Pass this first lot of claims and then do an impact assessment”

Julie Girling MEP: “Pass this first lot of claims and then do an impact assessment”

Julie Girling

Member of the European Parliament, The Conservatives

Irish MEP: “We have opened a can of worms that EFSA and the Commission would have much preferred remained closed”

Irish MEP: “We have opened a can of worms that EFSA and the Commission would have much preferred remained closed”

Marian Harkin

Member of the European Parliament, Alliance of Liberals and Democrats...

UK whey protein market hitting ‘critical mass’ - Volac

UK whey protein market hitting ‘critical mass’ - Volac

Mark Neville

Head of Lifestyle Ingredients, Volac

DSM ‘Sight and Life’ turns 25 and sees brighter future for the malnourished

DSM ‘Sight and Life’ turns 25 and sees brighter future for the malnourished

Dr Klaus Kraemer

Director , DSM Sight and Life Programme

GAIN ups micronutrient fight against global malnutrition

GAIN ups micronutrient fight against global malnutrition

Larry Umanna

Nigeria country manager, GAIN

EFSA is right to dismiss “overrated” peer-reviewed probiotic science: Consultant

EFSA is right to dismiss “overrated” peer-reviewed probiotic science: Consultant

The European Food Safety Authority (EFSA) should discount probiotic studies that have passed peer-review...

Genomics fires Microbiota 2011 to new heights

Genomics fires Microbiota 2011 to new heights

Jean Michel Pommet, founder, Microbiota

Koos Oosterhaven, business manager, NIZO Food Research

Taura targets Asian and US markets with fruit and veg inclusions

Taura targets Asian and US markets with fruit and veg inclusions

Mattias Van Uffelen

Head of sales for Europe & UK , Taura Natural Ingredients

Beneo: “We need to have a new future now”

Beneo: “We need to have a new future now”

Anke Sentko

Vice president of regulatory affairs and nutrition communication, Beneo Group

Healthier overall dietary patterns linked to slashed risk of diabetes

Healthier overall dietary patterns linked to slashed risk of diabetes

Lee Ashton

Alpro Foundation award winner (UK - 2011), University of Leeds

Ingredient suppliers grasping opportunity inside Asia’s many markets

Ingredient suppliers grasping opportunity inside Asia’s many markets

Bram van Hulsen, regional director, Asia Pacific, Danisco BioActives

Henning Villadsen, sales director, Asia Pacific, Middle East and Africa,...

Cold chain challenges and infant formula drive Asian dairy demand

Cold chain challenges and infant formula drive Asian dairy demand

Raneck Cayen

Sales director, functional products, Agropur

Vitamin D deficiency is an Asian problem too (despite the sun)

Vitamin D deficiency is an Asian problem too (despite the sun)

Campaigns against vitamin D deficiency have gained prominence in the western world but the...

EFSA boosts Asian prospects for Spanish olive extract supplier

EFSA boosts Asian prospects for Spanish olive extract supplier

Spanish supplier Genosa brought its olive extracts to Vitafoods Asia in Hong Kong this...

‘Robust systems’ needed to monitor botanical substitutes, says Prof

‘Robust systems’ needed to monitor botanical substitutes, says Prof

Professor Monique Simmonds

Head of the Sustainable Uses of Plants Group, Royal Botanic...

Good supply chain is just as important as identification of botanical ingredients

Good supply chain is just as important as identification of botanical ingredients

Professor Monique Simmonds

Head of the Sustainable Uses of Plants Group, Royal Botanic...

IPA co-founder: EU probiotic approach is “dirty pool”

IPA co-founder: EU probiotic approach is “dirty pool”

Jarrow Rogovin

President and owner, Jarrow Formulas

Beneo: Prebiotic health claim rejections have put prospects “on hold”

Beneo: Prebiotic health claim rejections have put prospects “on hold”

Yves Servotte

Executive board member, Beneo Group

Clinical trial design in the new EU health claims regime: “Now we have to work on the borderline”

Clinical trial design in the new EU health claims regime: “Now we have to work on the borderline”

Roberta Re, PhD, nutrition research manager, Leatherhead Food Research

Joerg Gruenwald, PhD, co-founder and president, analyze&realize

Nutrigenetics “was clearly a too-focused approach”, says nutrigenomicist

Nutrigenetics “was clearly a too-focused approach”, says nutrigenomicist

Dr Sebastien Massart

Business development manager, DNA Vision

Researchers close in on the ‘black box’ of bacterial vaginosis

Researchers close in on the ‘black box’ of bacterial vaginosis

Dr Jacques Ravel

Associate professor , The University of Maryland’s Institute of Genome...

Big future forecast for pre- and probiotics

Big future forecast for pre- and probiotics

Dr Dirk Gevers

Research leader, Broad Institute of MIT and Harvard in Boston,...

FHI "getting its act together" for positive EFSA opinions

FHI "getting its act together" for positive EFSA opinions

Jens Bleiel

CEO, Food for Health Ireland

Oat beta glucan makes claims on European cholesterol market

Oat beta glucan makes claims on European cholesterol market

Ruedi Duss

managing director, CreaNutrition

Stepan ends years of North American isolationism with strategic European nutrition shift

Stepan ends years of North American isolationism with strategic European nutrition shift

Emile Henein

Global business manager, Stepan Lipid Nutrition

Are Millennials the next big opportunity for the natural product industry?

Are Millennials the next big opportunity for the natural product industry?

Jeff Hilton

President and co-founder, Integrated Marketing Group (IMG)

Scalable new sources of omega-3 key to success for algae oils

Scalable new sources of omega-3 key to success for algae oils

Leslie van der Meulen

VP Business Development, AuroraAlgae

GOED explains its “big plans” for omega-3 health claims in 2012

GOED explains its “big plans” for omega-3 health claims in 2012

With the volume of omega-3 science tripling in 10 years, the world’s leading omega-3...

US businesses face rude shock as EU health claims laws loom

US businesses face rude shock as EU health claims laws loom

Martin Last

Chairman , UK Health Food Manufacturer’s Association (HFMA)

Horphag Research: We're going after sports nutrition and women's health

Horphag Research: We're going after sports nutrition and women's health

Markus Beba

VP Sales & Business Development, Horphag Research

The Beauty From Within Conference is back with a packed programme!

The second Beauty From Within conference will open its doors in Paris on October...

BASF 'impressed' with Cognis integration, expecting more M&A

BASF 'impressed' with Cognis integration, expecting more M&A

Samy Jandali

VP of nutrition and health North America, BASF

WWF on krill: "World’s largest under-exploited fishery"

WWF on krill: "World’s largest under-exploited fishery"

Nina Jensen, conservation director at the World Wildlife Fund, Norway

Matts Johansen, executive vice president for sales and marketing, Aker...

New dosage forms drive supplements growth but is social media helping?

New dosage forms drive supplements growth but is social media helping?

Jeff Hilton

Co-founder, Integrated Marketing Group

Danisco on probiotic health claims: “We have made great progress”

Danisco on probiotic health claims: “We have made great progress”

Fabienne Saadane-Oaks

President, Danisco Bioactives

EU regulatory experts debate herbs (don’t panic) and health claims (shout louder)

EU regulatory experts debate herbs (don’t panic) and health claims (shout louder)

Joerg Gruenwald, PhD, owner, analyze&realize

Christiane Alexander, PhD, senior consultant, analyze&realize

Permission to buy: Inside the new healthy consumer paradigm

Permission to buy: Inside the new healthy consumer paradigm

Peter Wennstrom

President, Healthy Marketing Team

DHA omega-3 may offer sports protection

DHA omega-3 may offer sports protection

DHA (docosahexaenoic acid) is the critical omega-3 fatty acid in the brain and research...