Breaking News on Supplements, Health & Nutrition - Europe US edition | APAC edition

News > Research

Read more breaking news



Probiotic society disputes research bias accusations


By Shane Starling+

Last updated on 08-Jan-2013 at 11:49 GMT2013-01-08T11:49:32Z

Probiotic research has nothing to hide, says ISAPP
Probiotic research has nothing to hide, says ISAPP

The International Scientific Association for Probiotics and Prebiotics (ISAPP) has refuted accusations that probiotic researchers under-report negative or neutral results due to corporate interest.

The assertions were made in a letter to the editor of the European Journal of Epidemiology titled, ‘Publication biases in probiotics’ late last year.

It stated in part: “In humans the investigator hypothesis and the sponsor interest were both in favor of a probiotic effect on digestive diseases that may have led to the unreport [sic] of opposite results”.

The letter went on to say conflicts of interest were also under-reported.

ISAPP said the statements were unfounded and that it supported publication of all probiotic human trials along with the registration of trials before they begin.

“We disagree with this statement, which is not supported by any specific evidence," ISAPP said. "In addition, the term ‘opposite results’ is unfortunate, since the ‘opposite’ of a health benefit is presumably a negative health impact. This implies that probiotic investigators may be concealing evidence that probiotics may pose a threat to human health.”

“The authors presumably mean that studies failing to document a benefit from probiotic intervention (null studies) are under-reported. While this may be the case, it is well known that journals tend to accept and publish positive clinical studies to a greater extent than ones that fail to demonstrate a benefit.”

Systematic reviews

The California-based group pointed out however that many systematic reviews of probiotic clinical trials included, “null studies”.  

“Indeed, in some cases the conclusion of these systematic reviews is that there is either inconclusive or insufficient evidence to merit a recommendation for probiotic use in a given indication. This is scarcely a testament to an under-reporting of null studies.”

“We submit, therefore, that there is no evidence that publication bias is more prevalent in the reporting of clinical trials involving probiotics than is the case for any other therapeutic category.”

Conflict of interest

ISAPP challenged the two letter writers to name and shame conflicts of interest abuse, if they knew of specific instances where this had occurred.

“If Million and Raoult are aware of instances where scientists in any field of study conceal data because the outcomes ‘were not the initial work hypothesis, or the funding purpose’, they should challenge those scientists directly, rather than make broad statements about probiotic research or any other discipline of scientific investigation,” it wrote.

The probiotic research literature amounts to around 7000 papers published over several decades.  

Probiotech and Microbiota 2013

For the latest in probiotic research and its business application, Probiotech and Microbiota 2013 joins two conferences to join the dots between the lab and leading edge pre- and probiotic products in food, supplements and cosmetics.

Find out more here .

2 comments (Comments are now closed)

lung infections

I am interested in probiotic and prebiotic research as they build immune defenses.

Report abuse

Posted by nicola Pilkington
10 February 2013 | 18h342013-02-10T18:34:05Z

Two issues in proverbs

Two important issues emerge in this article: 1) Scientific research is increasingly dependent on corporate funding and 2) We should know that for every positive result published there many negative ones that will never be published. In other words, “You cannot be judge and prosecutor” and “He who knows not and knows not he knows not: he is a fool - shun him. He who knows not and knows he knows not: he is simple - teach him. He who knows and knows not he knows: he is asleep - wake him. He who knows and knows he knows: he is wise - follow him.”

Report abuse

Posted by Martin Macouzet
08 January 2013 | 17h362013-01-08T17:36:23Z

Related products