Portion size not fat intake blamed for US obesity

Related tags Nutrition

The "French paradox" - rich cuisine and a slender population - can
be explained in part by portions that are significantly smaller in
French restaurants and supermarkets than in their American
counterparts, say researchers.

The "French paradox" - the intriguing phenomenon that pitches France's rich cuisine against a slender population - can be explained in part by portions that are significantly smaller in French restaurants and supermarkets than in their American counterparts. So say researchers at the University of Pennsylvania and CNRS in Paris, who compared the size of restaurant meals, single-serve foods and cookbook portions on both sides of the Atlantic.

"The French paradox is only a paradox if one assumes that dietary fat is the major cause of obesity and cardiovascular disease,"​ said Paul Rozin, professor of psychology at Penn and lead author of a paper in the September issue of the journal Psychological Science. "However, recent studies suggest that the importance of fat intake as a risk factor has been greatly exaggerated.

While the French eat more fat than Americans, they probably eat slightly fewer calories, which when compounded over years can amount to substantial differences in weight."

The French paradox has long stymied American dieters and scientists, puzzled by the ability of the French to remain trim while downing buttery croissants, creamy brie and decadent pastries. Just 7 per cent of French adults are obese, compared to 22 per cent of Americans, and the mortality rate from heart disease is significantly lower in France.

Rozin and his colleagues weighed portions at 11 comparable pairs of eateries in Paris and Philadelphia, including fast-food outlets, pizzerias, ice cream parlors and a variety of ethnic restaurants. They found the mean portion size across all Paris establishments was 277 grams, compared to a mean in Philadelphia of 346 grams - 25 per cent more than in Paris.

In just one of the 11 comparisons, between Hard Rock Cafes in both cities, were the Parisian portions larger. Three other international restaurant chains consistently served larger portions in the US, and Philadelphia's Chinese restaurants served meals that were on average 72 per cent heftier than those served by Chinese restaurants in Paris.

The researchers also examined references to portion size in Philadelphia and Paris editions of the 2000 Zagat restaurant guide. Serving sizes were not only mentioned roughly three times as frequently in reviews of Philadelphia restaurants, but, of these mentions, fully 88 per cent described large portions, compared to just 52 per cent in Paris.

"Many studies have shown that, if food is moderately palatable, people tend to consume what is put in front of them and generally consume more when offered more food,"​ Rozin said. "Much discussion of the 'obesity epidemic' in the US has focused on personal willpower, but our study shows that the environment also plays an important role and that people may be satisfied even if served less than they would normally eat."

Extending their approach to single-serve foods sold in supermarkets, Rozin and colleagues found 14 of 17 items studied were larger in American stores. For example, a candy bar sold in Philadelphia was 41 per cent larger than the same product in Paris, a soft drink was 52 per cent larger, a hot dog was 63 per cent larger and a carton of yoghurt was 82 per cent larger.

Rozin's co-authors on the Psychological Science paper are Kimberly Kabnick and Erin Pete at Penn, who conducted the work as part of their senior Psychology Honors thesis, and Claude Fischler and Christy Shields at CNRS. Their work was sponsored by the National Institute on Drug Abuse.

Related topics Research Suppliers

Related news

Follow us


View more