Misleading labeling found on St John's wort supplements

Related tags St john Pharmacology

The real amount of active ingredient in over-the-counter St John's
wort 'varies greatly' and can be up to 114 per cent of the amount
on the label, according to a new study in the Journal of the
Science of Food and Agriculture.

Professor Miao-Lin Hu and fellow researchers at the National Chung-Sing University in Taiwan looked at five commercial St John's wort products, purchased from ordinary Californian health food stores.

They analysed the amounts of hypericin and pseudohypericin, the two active ingredients that are reported to have antidepressant and antiviral effects. They then compared their results with the manufacturers' label.

None of the labels claimed to contain pseudohypericin, although in actual fact it was present in 'much higher' quantities than hypericin. Actual amounts of hypericin ranged from 1.7 to 38.5 per cent of the claimed amount, report the researchers.

When total hypericin (both active ingredients) was measured, the actual figure was up to 114 per cent of the claimed amount.

The active ingredients in St John's wort affects the same metabolic pathway as other prescription drugs used to treat depression and migraine, as well as drugs commonly used to treat heart disease and some cancers. There is also concern that it can affect the contraceptive pill.

Most St John's wort packaging carries a warning to consult a doctor when taking prescription drugs for these and other conditions, but doctors currently have no way of knowing how accurate the rest of the label is, said the researchers.

"Inaccurate labelling has at least one of two effects. The first is potentially to lead to incorrect dose when the label information is complied with. The second is the potential to degrade the perceived significance of the label information amongst either dispensing practitioners, or the patients. This perception could then carry over to more significant drugs,"​ commented Jonathan Berman, from the Health and Safety Group at the UK-based Society of Chemical Industry​, which publishes the journal.

Researchers are increasingly investigating awareness of interactions between herbals and drugs. Last year, a British study suggested that one in 20 people are taking potentially dangerous combinations of herbal and prescription medicines. The researchers said health professionals need to increase their herbal knowledge to respond to the boom in alternative and herbal medicines in the UK.

Related topics Supplements Botanicals Polyphenols

Related news

Related products

show more

Follow us

Products

View more

Webinars