Traditional use of herbs should be considered in claims, says AHPA

Related tags Dietary supplement Federal trade commission American herbal products association

The American Herbal Products Association (AHPA) has asked the FDA
to take into account relevant information on the traditional use of
herbs when substantiating claims for products that contain them.

The industry association's comments are in response to the publication of the FDA's draft guidance on dietary supplement claims in November 2004. This set out the amount, type, and quality of evidence that it recommends a manufacturer have, in order to substantiate a structure/function claim.

The agency also stated that it intends to apply a standard for substantiating dietary supplements claims that is consistent with its standard of "competent and reliable scientific evidence"​.

"Substantiation of a traditional claim for an herbal product should not require new clinical data so long as the product formulation, dose, and claim conform to established traditional usage records,"​ said Michael McGuffin, AHPA's president.

Other US bodies are more open to taking historical or traditional use of herbs into account, according to the association.

The Federal Trade Commission (FTC) has suggested that claims based on this could be presented "in such a way that consumers understand that the sole basis for the claim is a history of use of the product for a particular purpose"​.

This approach would depend on ensuring that the product is marketed in ways consistent with traditional uses - a caveat also issued by the Commission on Dietary Supplement Labels, which added that such claims would need to be "carefully qualified to prevent misleading consumers"​.

McGuffin noted that other countries, such as Canada, Australia and countries in the EU, allow for traditional use claims for herbal products within their policies.

The FDA is also soliciting comments regarding the premarket notification period for new dietary ingredients (NDIs). The notice was originally published on 20 October with a 45-day comment period, but this was extended until early February following requests from the AHPA and four other trade associations. A spokesperson for AHPA confirmed that it plans to submit comments.

Related topics Botanicals

Related news

Related products

show more

An Insights-driven Holistic Approach to Health

An Insights-driven Holistic Approach to Health

Content provided by Lipofoods, a Lubrizol Company | 25-Sep-2023 | Product Brochure

As they adopt the notion of holistic health, proactive consumers are driving the demand for products that have science-backed ingredients and offer sensory...

A Lifetime of Healthy Aging: White Paper

A Lifetime of Healthy Aging: White Paper

Content provided by Gencor | 16-Aug-2023 | White Paper

Live a lifetime of healthy aging with gold standard, clinically-researched ingredients. At Gencor, we are proud to offer ingredients for healthy ageing...

Ingredients designed for women to empower women

Ingredients designed for women to empower women

Content provided by Gencor | 03-Jul-2023 | White Paper

At Gencor, we understand that women have different needs at the different stages of their lives – and that’s why we have clinically effective ingredients...

Related suppliers

Follow us


View more