What degree of evidence is required to make an EU health claim?

By Dr Christiane Alexander

- Last updated on GMT

What degree of evidence is required to make an EU health claim?

Related tags Nutrition

Eight years after the EU nutrition and health claims regulation (NHCR) came into force the question of how to win a health claim is still not satisfactorily answered in the eyes of many food operators.

So argues Dr Christiane Alexander, business development manager at German contract research organisation and consultancy, analyse&realize (a&r), in this guest article.

Recent cases like the negative opinions for CLA (conjugated linoleic acid – for safety considerations), coffee C21 or pomegranate pomace extract (human clinical evidence accepted but mode-of-action data found to be too weak), showed applied assessment standards are often unpredictable for industry.

In recently published articles in Annals of Nutrition & Metabolism​ (Bernhardt et al., 2015), as well as Nutrafoods​ (Bernhardt et al., 2014), BioTeSys, a&r, the European Nutraceutical Association and the Osteoarthritis Research Center share their view on what degree of evidence should be required to make a health claim.

Yes a high degree of evidence is always desirable for health products but preventive nutrition seeks to support tissues at an early stage of imbalanced physiology. Such a status is characterised by rather small biomarker changes indicating disease risk or maintenance of health in the general population.

EFSA judgement on joint claims

Joint health is a very good example. In the broader picture joint health is characterised by the World Health Organisation (WHO) as one of two conditions with 'high burden diseases with no curative treatments'. This presents a major challenge for the public health system, both in terms of epidemiology and health economics.

It is a major health area but all joint nutrients have been rejected by EFSA’s Panel on Dietetic Products, Nutrition and Allergies (NDA) several times. Go into a pharmacy, health food store, supermarket or online retailer, and glucosamine products or chondroitin and many other supplement categories, bare no information about their intended use.

For glucosamine, promising scientific evidence for its beneficial role in joint health exists, but it is challenging if not impossible to prove a positive, preventative effect in a healthy population under the current EFSA requirements. EFSA guidance​, produced in 2012, has not helped matters.

Unlike in diseased populations, healthy subject changes in cartilage mass or disturbances in joint function, like joint stiffness and pain, are not measurable to the required extent. But other measures are valid such as biomarkers of joint metabolism in healthy populations.

In light of this, the authors advocate that EFSA and the European Commission accept promising emerging evidence, based on reasonable scientific agreement in the field of nutrition science.

Accepting this approach would allow consumers to be informed about potential health benefits through qualified wordings, whilst upholding benefit-risk principles that defines EU food safety together with epidemiological and health economic factors.

Related news

Show more

Related products

show more

Is your brand reputation at risk?

Is your brand reputation at risk?

Content provided by FoodChain ID | 04-Oct-2023 | White Paper

FoodChain ID has developed a new white paper, “Current Food Supply Chain Threats - Is Your Company's Brand Reputation at Risk?” examining recent regulatory...

Discover how to enhance ingredient functionality

Discover how to enhance ingredient functionality

Content provided by Lonza | 04-Oct-2023 | Product Brochure

Consumer demand for capsules shows no sign of slowing down—they are the globally preferred dosage form for 50% of consumers. But in an increasingly saturated...

An Insights-driven Holistic Approach to Health

An Insights-driven Holistic Approach to Health

Content provided by Lipofoods, a Lubrizol Company | 25-Sep-2023 | Product Brochure

As they adopt the notion of holistic health, proactive consumers are driving the demand for products that have science-backed ingredients and offer sensory...

Related suppliers

1 comment

Guide to substantiation of health claims for bioactive compounds and functional foods

Posted by Carlos J,

Regarding this topic, the International Journal of Food Sciences and Nutrition has recently published the Supplement “Guide to substantiation of health claims for bioactive compounds and functional foods” (http://www.tandfonline.com/toc/iijf20/66/sup1).This Guide, Open Access for several months, has been prepared by the Steering Committee of the INCOMES project, a public-private research Spanish Consortium comprised by 10 food companies and over 20 research agents, co-funded by the Spanish Government.

Report abuse

Follow us


View more