3 ways ‘shocking’ Italian botanical ruling has voided the health claim regulation

By Annie Harrison-Dunn contact

- Last updated on GMT

One year on and Italian courts have scrapped the €250,000 fine against Named S.p.A for misleading disease claims for Alzheimer’s, Parkinson’s, cancer and AIDS.
One year on and Italian courts have scrapped the €250,000 fine against Named S.p.A for misleading disease claims for Alzheimer’s, Parkinson’s, cancer and AIDS.

Related tags: Health claims regulation, European union

Italian courts have defended a botanical company’s right to make AIDS and Alzheimer’s disease claims – overturning a previous ruling from its national competition authority and potentially voiding the EU health claims regulation.

In September last year the Italian Competition Authority (AGCM) imposed a fine of €250,000​ on the company Named S.p.a for misleading press, radio and TV advertising for its supplement Immun’Age.

The company claimed its fermented papaya extract could help fight against serious diseases like Alzheimer’s, Parkinson’s, cancer and AIDS.

The fine against the claims – which AGCM said at the time​ were “untrue or at least ambiguous”​ – was said to be the largest ever levied for a breach of the EU nutrition and health claims regulation (NHCR) in any EU member state and the company was given 30 days to pay up.

Papaya-liar-Italy-issues-250-000-fine-over-distorted-health-claims_strict_xxl
The Immun'Age website last year. It appears to have been changed now. 

However, one year on and an appeal to Italian courts has overturned the AGCM’s ruling​ – cancelling the fine and ordering the pair to share court costs.

Dr Luca Bucchini, managing director of Rome-based Hylobates Consulting, said the ruling had huge implications for the way in which the NHCR is enforced and the role and source of evidence required in that enforcement.

He said the decision was all too absurd to be true”​ and had in essence “voided the health claims regulation in Italy”.

“We are all in shock here,” ​Bucchini told us.   

So what did the courts say?

1. All botanical claims okay – not just those on hold

immune echinacea botanical herbal

According to an unofficial list circulated by the UK Department of Health last year, there are over 2000 on-hold botanical health claims.

The backlog was caused by disagreement over the type of evidence needed to prove efficacy for these plant-based ingredients. 

While this regulatory limbo prevailled it was agreed that any pending health claims could continue to be used, according to transition conditions of the health claims regulation.

However, this latest ruling went a step beyond this and said any health claim – pending or otherwise – could be used.

The court said it found no evidence that Named S.p.a’s claims were prohibited, and even if they were it would be up to the member state authority to provide reasoning for this.

2. Unauthorised doesn’t mean misleading

The courts said a health claim that was not authorised under the claims regulation was not automatically misleading, a view contrary to the interpretation of member state authorities like the UK’s Advertising Standards Authority (ASA).

Bucchini said the ruling meant: Authorities should prove that they are misleading, not assume so.” 

By this logic enforcement authorities like the AGCM cannot rely on assessment and approval or rejection from the European Food Safety Authority (EFSA) as a reference point of legality.

consumer supplements

Instead they would have to examine the scientific evidence provided by firms, and potentially accept unauthorised health claims.

3. Antioxidants can help AIDS, cancer and Alzheimer’s

The court said research had linked an antioxidant-rich diet with preventive and curative effects of diseases and that this was also common public knowledge.

“Therefore it's not implausible that a food supplement with papaya helps with cancer, Alzheimer and cancer, and can be legally advertised as such,”​ Bucchini said.

“Such a link seems plausible to the court - even if not even liberal America allows such claims on supplements.”

What happens now

eu law legal case court europe regulation

The ruling was made by the Lazio court for regional administrative matters, but there is still a chance the higher court (Consiglio di Stato) would overturn it.

However, if the ruling stands Bucchini said Italy could be in breach of EU law. Member states are not allowed to violate European rules even if its national courts demand it.

Instead member states must change laws so the ‘illegal’ court ruling does not apply.

“But there's still a fair chance that Named avoids any fine, and the ruling sets a precedent for at least some time.”

A spokesperson for the AGCM said it did not comment on ongoing court cases. 

Named S.p.A did not respond to our request for comment in time for the publication of this article. 

Related news

Show more

Related products

show more

Vitamins & Minerals as Nature intended

Vitamins & Minerals as Nature intended

LEHVOSS Nutrition– Gee Lawson | 12-Dec-2019 | Data Sheet

LEHVOSS Nutrition offer a range of natural, organic certified, vegan and active vitamins and minerals. These are offered as “whole-food complexes” in their...

Related suppliers

3 comments

Common sense?

Posted by Paulo,

Is it really common sense to make outrageous medicinal and health claims without actual proof? Or is it businesses selling wishful thinking at the best and others, bluntly, exploiting consumers and making an awful lot of money in the process.

Report abuse

"shocking" Italian botanical ruling

Posted by MURIEL TOFFOLI,

MERAVIGLIOSO!!! WELL DONE, ITALY - DOWN WITH EFSA AND BIG PHARMA!!!!!

Report abuse

Common sense at last?

Posted by Michel,

Botanicals have been around a lot longer than these draconian laws. Requiring botanical suppliers to PROVE with human trials the continued use of botanicals to deal with common illnesses is only designed to control the population and make money for the multi-nationals. This continued attack on the botanical industry and the accumulated oral knowledge about their effect on the human body only ensures that a thriving black market for these products will develop.

Report abuse

Follow us

Featured Events

View more

Products

View more

Webinars