Breastfeeding exclusively may not be best strategy for bone health: Study

By Louisa Richards

- Last updated on GMT

Nearly 5000 children were studied as part of the Generation R study, a Netherlands population-based prospective cohort study from foetal life onwards. © / Solovyova
Nearly 5000 children were studied as part of the Generation R study, a Netherlands population-based prospective cohort study from foetal life onwards. © / Solovyova

Related tags: Osteoporosis, Breastfeeding

Breastfeeding exclusively may not be the best strategy for bone health, results from the 5000-strong Generation R study have suggested. 

“In this prospective cohort study, ever breast-feeding as compared with never breast-feeding was positively associated with bone mass in six-year-old children, but exclusive breast-feeding for 4 months or longer was not positively associated with childhood bone outcomes,”​ the authors from the University Medical Center Rotterdam wrote. 

Early life nutrition is an important factor in achieving peak bone mass in adulthood and future risk of osteoporosis. Components of breast milk may be beneficial to bone development but some nutrients such as calcium and vitamin D may be higher in formula milk. 

Writing in the British Journal of Nutrition​, the scientists said it could be speculated that late introduction of micronutrients present in solid foods may be adversely related to bone development, also early introduction of solids has been linked to increased risk of obesity which may positively influence bone development through mechanical loading by body weight. 

Although the present study results do not support a beneficial effect of exclusive breastfeeding for longer than four months, the scientists were keen to point out they had no detailed information on frequency and quantity of solid foods consumed and there was no evidence for a dose-response relationship. 

Nearly 5000 children were studied as part of the Generation R study, a Netherlands population-based prospective cohort study from foetal life onwards. Information was collected from the mothers by questionnaire about breastfeeding duration and exclusiveness, and timing of introduction of solid foods.

The bones of the study

A dual-energy X-ray absorptiometry scan was performed on the children at six years of age and bone mineral density (BMD), bone mineral content (BMC) and bone area (BA) were analysed. Results were adjusted for vitamin D supplementation. 

Children who had never been breast fed had lower BMD, BMC and BA compared to children who had at some point ('ever') been breastfed. 

However, children who had received formula milk or solid foods in addition to breast milk within the first four months of life had higher BMD and BMC and lower BA compared to children who were breast fed exclusively.

Breast-feeding for longer than four months was not associated with more positive bone outcomes, they found. 

Introduction of solids before the age of four months was associated with a higher BMD and BMC, compared to introduction after this age. 

The authors said additional confounding factors, further bone assessment techniques, and collection of fracture events may be factors to consider in future studies. Socio-demographic and lifestyle factors may also have influenced some of the results. 

“Further research in other populations is needed to confirm our findings. In addition, future studies should investigate the underlying mechanisms and evaluate whether the observed differences have consequences for bone health in later life,” ​they wrote.


Source: British Journal of Nutrition​ 

Published online ahead of print, doi:10.1017/S0007114515005462 

Associations of breast-feeding patterns and introduction of solid foods with childhood bone mass: The Generation R Study 

Authors: E.H. van den Hooven et al.

Related news

Show more

Related products

show more



PLT Health Solutions | 22-Jun-2022 | Product Brochure

Earthlight® Whole Food Vitamin D is a clean label ingredient that can help you create cutting-edge fortified foods and supplements. Low use levels mean...

Whitepaper: Optimizing immunity with vitamin D

Whitepaper: Optimizing immunity with vitamin D

DSM Nutritional Products | 16-Jun-2022 | Technical / White Paper

With vitamin D science evolving rapidly since the COVID-19 pandemic, our new whitepaper breaks down the latest research on the role of vitamin D in supporting...

Innovative colic solutions

Innovative colic solutions


Colic is one of the most frequent reasons for visits to the pediatrician and can often lead to parental and infant exhaustion. As a functional gastrointestinal...

Register for free

Happier with indication-specific probiotics

Happier with indication-specific probiotics

Winclove Probiotics | 07-Jun-2022 | Product Brochure

From the very founding of Winclove Probiotics, our aim to help people, society, and the world has been an essential part of our business DNA.

Related suppliers



Posted by JA Larson,

Trying to correlate breast feeding with bone status 6 years later is tough.

All breast milk is not equal. Breast milk is a function of mom’s diet. For example, in Wagner et al, we see breast milk can be deficient in D.

Report abuse

Fruits and Veg Improve Breast Milk

Posted by Tomaj,

If the mothers aren't getting enough vitamins from their diet, it follows that the breast milk will be inferior to solid foods.

Report abuse

Follow us


View more