ECJ alcohol ruling strengthens EU health claims position

By Shane Starling

- Last updated on GMT

Related tags: European union

The ECJ: The court has backed the broad position of the EU health claims regulation
The ECJ: The court has backed the broad position of the EU health claims regulation
The Court of Justice of the European Union (ECJ) has given strength to EU health claim laws by backing health claims of “temporary or fleeting effects”.

At first glance the ruling – in relation to an alcohol case in Germany – may appear to open the door to the kind of vague claims the EU nutrition and health claims regulation (NHCR) seeks to eradicate, but legal experts said it did not necessarily undermine the tough scientific criteria in place to back claims.

“This broadens the scope of the regulation for sure as it says you can restrict free speech when there are public health concerns,”​ said Luca Bucchini, PhD, MPH, the managing director of Italian-based Hylobates Consulting.

The ruling said claims such as “aids digestion”​ were permissible under the NHCR, even as guidance issued by the European Food Safety Authority (EFSA) has indicated such general claims were difficult to validate.

“People thought weak claims would fall out of the scope of the regulation, but while this backs the NHCR, it does not challenge the scientific principles of the regulation. It just says if a claim is against the public health interest then it should not be permissible.”

Other NCHR challenges

Sebastian Melchor Romero, partner at K&L Gates in Brussels, agreed the ruling strengthened the NHCR position, although it may not be so relevant in bolstering the validity of the NHCR in separate legal challenges to the regulation yet to be heard by the ECJ.

“This ruling confirms broad food and health relationships, but the other cases are about procedural elements of the NHCR, so it may not help much there, but it certainly won’t harm the position of the NHCR either.”

He added: "The EU adopted a broad interpretation of the definition of 'health claim' by ruling that claims for merely temporary or fleeting effects of a food on human health, such as in the claim 'easily digestible', are indeed health claims." 

The ruling can be found here.

Related news

Show more

Related products

show more

Aquamin & Microbiome Enhance Immunity Naturally

Aquamin & Microbiome Enhance Immunity Naturally

Marigot Ltd | 24-Jun-2020 | Technical / White Paper

Aquamin is a unique, natural plant multi-mineral offering for gut health with 39 peer reviewed publications to support its unique health properties, enhancing...

BERGAVIT™40:THE INNOVATION FOR CHOLESTEROL CONTROL

BERGAVIT™40:THE INNOVATION FOR CHOLESTEROL CONTROL

BIONAP Srl | 13-Apr-2020 | Product Brochure

THE INNOVATION AT BIONAP’S LABORATORIES NEVER STOP. BERGAVIT™ is able to reduce and control plasmatic “bad lipid” levels (total cholesterol, LDL and triglycerides)...

Related suppliers

Sportsandactivenutrition

SERIES INTRODUCTION

23 SEPTEMBER 2020 | 10.30AM CET


Follow us

Products

View more

Webinars