Solae: EFSA soy-cholesterol opinion is “disconcerting”

By Shane Starling

- Last updated on GMT

Related tags Soy protein

Leading soy supplier Solae has criticised the European Food Safety Authority (EFSA) for a selective approach that saw the agency’s health claims panel dismiss upward of 30 human intervention studies contained in an article 14, soy protein, cholesterol-lowering dossier.

“It is disconcerting that the EFSA panel considers the studies cited and analysed in nine peer-reviewed meta-analyses (based collectively on the existing soy protein and cholesterol literature) to not be designed appropriately to assess the effects of soy protein on cholesterol lowering,”​ the company said.

Solae Europe managing director Reinhart Schmitt told NutraIngredients this morning that while the company was disappointed with the opinion of EFSA’s Panel on Dietetic Products, Nutrition and Allergies (NDA), “it would not keep us from selling our product”.

Pure and formalistic approach

“EFSA have not said that soy cannot lower cholesterol rather they have said that there is insufficient evidence to prove that soy protein causes cholesterol reduction,” ​Schmitt said.

“They have taken a very narrow view of what a soy protein is so that soy isoflavones which they acknowledge can lower cholesterol, and soy protein isolates are not considered within their definition of soy protein. I am a chemist and I can understand their pure and formalistic approach but it is in defiance of the procedures of many other agencies around the world.”

The NDA opinion can be found here.

Defining soy protein

Two of the trade groups that participated in the submission – the European Vegetable Protein Federation (EUVEPRO) and the European Natural Soyfoods Manufacturers Association (ENSA) – issued statements highlighting the soy protein definition issue.

“EUVEPRO will contribute to clarifying scientific interpretations to the European Commission and EFSA NDA Panel in order to provide more clarity and precision on the definition of the term ‘soy protein’ as well as the mechanism by which the protein component of soy would exert the claimed effect,”​ EUVEPRO said.

The soy industry has noted how the NDA definition of soy protein differs from that of other agencies and the Codex Alimentarius which includes soy protein isolates, soy protein concentrates and soy protein flour in its official definition.

EUVEPRO and ENSA, along with Solae and others such as the UK-based Soy Protein Association, said they would submit comments to the Commission in the 30-day comment period.


Jean Christoph Kremer from EUVEPRO – which counts ADM, Cargill and Solae among its members – said the group was surprised by the opinion.

“We thought the dossier was strong enough,” ​he said, even after the NDA came back with additional questions regarding the data. “We were feeling comfortable. This is not good news but we will react firstly by submitting comments to Commission.”

Solae’s Schmitt said the company did not expect the NDA panel to change its opinion even after the comment period but that the Commission and member states may interpret the opinion more favourably due to them.

The comments may also have a bearing on two generic, article 13.1 soy-cholesterol lowering dossiers that are yet to be assessed by the NDA.

Soy-cholesterol lowering claims are approved in Japan, the US, the UK, South Africa, the Philippines, Brazil, Indonesia, Korea, Malaysia and Turkey.

Related news

Show more

Related products

show more

Sweetening solution for active nutrition

Sweetening solution for active nutrition

Content provided by ADM | 19-Feb-2024 | Case Study

When you add GrainSweet® Liquid Maltodextrin to your active nutrition applications, you get the production efficiencies, clean labels, and clean tastes...

Oats: A Superfood for Sport Nutrition and Health

Oats: A Superfood for Sport Nutrition and Health

Content provided by Fazer Mills | 26-Jan-2024 | White Paper

Oats are a versatile, affordable, and easy to use superfood that can offer many health benefits and a well-balanced nutritional profile for athletes.

Unlock the business potential of the protein trend

Unlock the business potential of the protein trend

Content provided by Valio | 24-Jan-2024 | White Paper

Read our white paper to learn how to overcome taste and texture challenges in protein products — and how to commercialise the protein trend by making delicious...

Related suppliers

Follow us


View more