EFSA health claim opinions

EFSA rejects glucosamine, coffee, diacylglycerol (DAG) oil health claims

By Shane Starling

- Last updated on GMT

Related tags Knee

Béres' glucosamine supplement may soon have to alter its marketing
Béres' glucosamine supplement may soon have to alter its marketing
The European Food Safety Authority (EFSA) has sent an ominous warning that recently-submitted health claim dossiers will fare any better than those that have gone before, with three fresh article 13.5 rejections.

Glucosamine (joint health), a coffee extract (DNA protection) and diacylglycerol (DAG) oil (weight management) were all rebuffed by EFSA’s Panel on Dietetic Products, Nutrition and Allergies (NDA).

Given the swathe of article 13.5 applications that have been arriving in the NDI’s inbox, hopeful to have applied learnings from more than 3000 opinions over three years, not to mention summits and guidelines, these three rejections, in particular the glucosamine opinion, will appear disturbing to industry.

However closer inspection reveals the dossiers to be lacking in real power.

Glucosamine

The glucosamine dossier submitted by Hungarian firm Béres Pharmaceuticals Ltd contained just two human intervention trials that the HND deemed relevant – one of which was conducted among a diseased population, the other was uncontrolled and provided inconclusive data, according to the NDA.

That opinion can be found here.

Coffee extracts

German firm Tchibo GmbH sought to link a reduction in ‘spontaneous DNA strand breaks’ and its coffee C21 extract. The NDA found one human study was not adequately controlled for confounding factors while other studies researched coffees but not coffee C21 and supporting animal and in vitro ​data was inconclusive.

That opinion can be found here.

DAG

A European subsidiary of Japanese company Kao Corporation proposed that diacylglycerol (DAG) oil could benefit weight loss when replacing vegetable oils. Kao highlighted seven randomised controlled trials (RCTs), but the NDA said six of the studies gave inconsistent and unconvincing results. The other had methodological limitatations.

An unpublished meta-analysis, “had a number of potential sources of bias and did not provide additional information for the scientific substantiation of the claim.”

That opinion can be found here.

The companies were not available at the time of publication.

The Béres dossier proposed the claim:“glucosamine sodium sulphate contributes to the protection of joint cartilage exposed to excessive motion or loading and helps to improve the range of motion in joints”.

Statements on the Béres website that may soon require changing include claims that its supplements could:

  • ease mild and moderately severe symptoms of the degenerative changes in the knee joint
  • ease the symptoms of osteoarthritis in the knee joint

Related news

Show more

Related products

show more

Nextida: Precision where it matters

Nextida: Precision where it matters

Content provided by Rousselot | 01-Jun-2024 | Product Brochure

NEXTIDA™ is an innovative platform of specific collagen peptide compositions with new targeted health benefits. Built and backed by science, Nextida stands...

Harness the power of algae for omega-3 innovation

Harness the power of algae for omega-3 innovation

Content provided by dsm-firmenich | 08-May-2024 | Insight Guide

Algal-sourced omega-3s have limitless potential, able to scale to meet the needs of our planet’s population with twice the potency – naturally – and all...

In Weight Management Go Beyond with Slendacor®

In Weight Management Go Beyond with Slendacor®

Content provided by PLT Health Solutions | 22-Feb-2024 | White Paper

Slendacor® is a synergistic, patented formulation of three standardized herbal extracts: turmeric (Curcuma longa), moringa (Moringa oleifera) and curry...

Related suppliers

2 comments

Dag oil

Posted by Carole Muniandy,

We need to purchase Solid lubricant (Dummy wax) & we expect your price for the same.

We use this wax to apply extrusion stem & dummy block while extruding process as lubricant. This helps to avoid bonding/pasting Aluminium with dummy block & stem.

Can u provide this product?
Regards
Carole
0122360192

Report abuse

DAG

Posted by Herman Rutner,

After reviewing the published DAG/MAG data myself, a lifelong industrial chemist, I find the rejection unreasonable. Both are intermediates in normal fat metabolism of dietary TAG's via in vivo enzymes in both energy production and storage. Replacing TAGs with DAG/MAG made ex vivo by the same enzymes eliminates the enzyme limited physiological conversion of TAGs which, if in excess of dietary needs, would be stored as body fat, ergo weight gain.
Regardless of the decision, consuming DAG/MAG, eg as found in some "reduced fat" cheeses, is advisable for weight control. Regrettably, the DAG/MA enriched Enova oil is no longer readily available in the USA.

Report abuse

Follow us

Products

View more

Webinars