Thorne survey exposes limits of AI wellness trust

"AI in particular is changing how people seek and interpret health information, creating new opportunities to make health guidance more relevant, personalized and accessible. Yet the value of any recommendation depends on the science, expertise, and understanding behind it," said Colin Watts, CEO at Thorne in the report.
"AI in particular is changing how people seek and interpret health information, creating new opportunities to make health guidance more relevant, personalized and accessible. Yet the value of any recommendation depends on the science, expertise, and understanding behind it," said Colin Watts, CEO at Thorne in the report. (Getty Images)

Thorne has expanded its use of artificial intelligence (AI) to help consumers choose supplements, but its latest research suggests the technology still has some way to go before people are willing to put its advice ahead of their healthcare provider’s.

The supplement company’s second annual Wellness Compass report found that 50% of respondents trusted AI for health and wellness advice, up 6 percentage points from 2025. However, that confidence did not necessarily translate into a willingness to follow its recommendations: when asked whose advice they would follow if AI and their healthcare provider disagreed, 34% of respondents chose their provider and just 6% chose AI.

Published this month, “The Wellness Clarity Gap” results draw on survey responses from 3,004 U.S. consumers, including a nationally representative sample of 1,000 adults and similarly sized groups of additional Gen Z and Millennial respondents.

The line of inquiry also reflects Thorne’s investment in AI technology: in January 2026, the company introduced Taia, an AI wellness advisor that uses the company’s scientific resources and product information to offer personalized supplement recommendations.

AI enters the supplement conversation

The company’s growing interest in AI comes as supplement brands seek greater visibility in AI-generated search results.

In October, NutraIngredients reported on research from Avenue Z showing that Thorne and Nature Made together accounted for 43% of AI share of voice in the multivitamin category.

Explore related questions

But visibility in AI-generated results is only part of the equation. The reliability of the health information being delivered is another consideration.

Academic research has also examined questions about the reliability of AI-generated supplement information.

A 2026 study published in PEC Innovation tested GPT-4 and GPT-4o on whether 30 dietary supplements were effective against six diseases. Researchers compared 360 AI responses with evidence-based assessments, finding agreement in 58.9% of GPT-4o responses and 55.6% of GPT-4 responses.

Different sources of wellness advice

The findings suggest that using AI for health information doesn’t necessarily mean relying on its advice. While 46% of respondents had used the technology to explore a potential health or wellness action, 73% still placed greater trust in human experts.

AI was also being used to interpret health information (26%) and decide on next steps (22%).

However, consumers’ definition of a trusted wellness expert varied by generation. Among Gen Z, 41% said they trusted certain influencers more than their own healthcare provider.

Influencers were also a source of wellness advice for 46% of Gen Z respondents, compared with 39% of those surveyed overall.

Supplement choices presented another difficulty. Some 54% of respondents were unsure which supplements were best suited to their needs, with the same percentage saying they would welcome more personalized guidance.

These findings point to an opportunity for personalized wellness tools, but also highlight the importance of establishing consumer confidence in the recommendations they provide.

For Thorne, the challenge is not simply getting consumers to use AI, but whether they will trust the recommendations it provides.

“We have more information about our health at our fingertips than ever before, but information alone doesn’t tell us what to do with it,” said Colin Watts, CEO of Thorne in a press statement.

“AI is already transforming how people access and interpret health information, but its value depends on the quality of the science and expertise behind it,” he added."