Beyond strains and CFU: Modern consumers demand holistic gut health solutions

The language of gut health marketing has shifted dramatically, from generic ‘good bacteria’ claims and ever-higher CFU counts to evidence-backed benefits and a growing emphasis on supporting the entire gut ecosystem.

Probiotics rocketed onto the nutrition market when Yakult launched the concept of ‘good bacteria’ in a bottle in Japan in 1935, with a marketing message which immediately broke a key barrier in the supplements industry.

“It was very clever the way they marketed that first Yakult product; right from the beginning it was sold as a daily ritual,” said Marit Veenstra, brand strategist at the marketing consultancy HMT, speaking at the Remedy Nutrafood CDMO Conference in Poland (Oct 22-23). “We know that consistency is an essential element of the efficacy of probiotics,” she added.

But, the stated benefits of ‘good bacteria’ and ‘gut health’ were always ‘intangible’. Veenstra told delegates, meaning repeat purchase relied solely on excellent consumer education and strong trust in the brand, both of which Yakult achieved.

The company maintained its monopoly on the market until Danone launched its Activia yogurt in Europe around 50 years after Yakult’s category creation, with a marketing campaign and packaging imagery which aimed to make the intangible, tangible.

“They talked about digestive health, as opposed to ‘good bacteria’, and used imagery on pack showing the stomach, making clear where the effects would be felt,” Veenstra said.

Competing CFU and delivery tech

With several brands entering the gut health arena through the 2000’s and 2010’s, differentiation became more challenging and many opted to compete based on their colony forming units (CFU), “but CFU doesn’t really mean anything to the consumer,” Veenstra stressed.

Explore related questions

As probiotic capsules and powders boomed, a growing number of studies revealed that many freeze-dried supplements died in stomach acid before reaching the colon.

In response, supplement brands shifted their marketing away from CFU counts toward delivery technology—such as enteric coatings, delayed-release capsules, and spore-forming strains—and made claims guaranteeing their bacteria would survive the stomach.

Veenstra told delegates this has evolved into a more ‘holistic’ conversation.

“Now, we have shifted away from just discussing the good bacteria and instead we see brands discuss ‘nourishing’ the gut microbiome as a whole ecosystem,” she said. “This creates a whole new world of language for the category with people now discussing the ecosystem and the gut barrier.”

When the focus moved from bacteria to the gut barrier the story became more tangible, she argued, as this opened up ‘a whole new world’ of conversations around gut-organ axes.

She highlighted one strong player in this space is Nordic Rebalance, with its fermented oat-based postbiotic ingredient ReFerm, which focuses its messaging and health claims around gut barrier integrity.

Discussing opportunities for further differentiation in the modern market, Veenstra stressed the importance of portraying quality and transparency through patented science-backed strains.

Brands can further instill trust in their products by building a niche for themselves within a target health area.

“If you can become known as an expert in that particular area of health, this is a great way to build trust and credibility in the consumer’s mind,” Veenstra noted.

Consumer experience is king

Although the market has benefited from the emergence of more accessible at-home gut health testing devices, allowing consumers to see the intangible benefits of probiotics, Veenstra argued the masses won’t buy into these kits.

She stressed if customers don’t feel a tangible benefit within weeks and they don’t enjoy the experience of consuming the product, they are extremely unlikely to keep taking it.

With this in mind, much of the new innovation in this category aims to provide an enjoyable experience for the consumer, with the majority of new launches sitting within functional food and drink rather than supplements, Veenstra highlighted.

“At the end of the day, consumers will stick to what they like and what they enjoy consuming,” she stressed. “The value is moving from what is inside the product, to what the consumer feels when they take the product.”